2008/04/30

林行止後悔

博客Gary Shiu,在其blog "Spontaneous Order" 有以下的短評:

[林行止說:]
"寫了三十多年政經評論,筆者對過去理直氣壯地維護資本主義制度頗生悔意,因為看到了太多不公平手段和欺詐性活動 ,而一些本以為放諸四海而皆准的理論則經不起現實考驗(比如價高必然使產量增加促致價格回順)……。筆者真的希望中國不要徹底走資,社會主義的確能夠維繫社會公平,中國若能定出一套在「向錢看」與社會公平間平衡發展的政策,中國的崛起才對提高人類福祉有積極意義!"

[Gary說:]
"This is from Hong Kong Economic Journal's famous columnist 林行止 .

Read the whole thing here. More comments later.

Social Justice? Are you kidding me, Mr Lam? There IS NOT an identity called society which makes economic decisions, and I thought we are over that idea DECADES AGO!
"

茶怪在他的blog作了以下的回應:

Putting the soundness of Mr. Lam's argument aside, Mr. Lam's statement represents a clear signal for the change of ideology in Hong Kong.

Mr. Lam's retreat means to Hong Kong's capitalism in 2008 what the fall of Berlin Wall meant to the world's socialism in 1989.

Mr. Lam established his newspaper to "educate" Hong Kong people about capitalism 30 years ago, when the mass public (if you don't like the word "public", it means many people) knew little about capitalism.

Although i feel conservative about his argument, i admire his courage of intellectual pursuit.

And if you watch TV, many people have become increasingly impatient about inequality (of outcomes). Hong Kong is changing, as being part of the world's bigger tide towards populism.

博客量子有另一套觀點,值得參考。

4 則留言:

Brian 說...

世界潮流再一次向左轉,已成趨勢。

茶怪 說...

下屆特首,我買曾德成!

匿名 說...

利潤最大化乃是元兇

匿名 說...

網主,好久不見.
原來林行止不是自由主義者,只是相反理論信徒.我覺得相反理論無錯呀!
林生經常過早轉彎的,所以自由主義還起碼有十年玩,放心.
我最最憂心的是政治上有右轉趨勢 - 民族主義. 我們這代人如見第三次世界大戰,我怕我唔識反應.